Seattle skyline with Space Needle
boam

The 8 Best Pizza Places Near Mercer Island

Updated: October 6, 2021

Craving pizza? These are Mercer Island’s best parlors for a slice on the run or an indulgent pie to linger over. We scrutinized millions of reviews and analyzed top local sites for this list of the best parlors in Mercer Island. Now all you need to do is decide between a stuffed calzone or classic Margarita pizza from the options below!

Find the perfect place

Mioposto

Pizza, $$, Mercer IslandPizza, $$Mercer Island
Google: 4.4
Yelp: 4.0

Island Crust Café

Pizza, $$, Mercer IslandPizza, $$Mercer Island
Google: 4.0
Yelp: 3.0

If you travel further

Rocco's

Pizza, $$, SeattlePizza, $$Seattle, Belltown
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.0
  • The Stranger, 2018

    Pizza Pie Face Off: Searching for the Best Slice in Seattle

    The Stranger, 2018
  • Thrillist, 2019

    Seattle's Best Pizzerias

    Thrillist, 2019

Dino's Tomato Pie

Pizza, $$, SeattlePizza, $$Seattle, Capitol Hill
Google: 4.3
Yelp: 3.5
  • Eater, 2020

    Seattle's Essential Pizza Restaurants

    Eater, 2020
  • The Stranger, 2018

    Pizza Pie Face Off: Searching for the Best Slice in Seattle

    The Stranger, 2018

Breezy Town Pizza

Pizza, $$, SeattlePizza, $$Seattle, Beacon Hill
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.5
  • Seattle Magazine, 2018

    The Best Pizza in Seattle

    Seattle Magazine, 2018
  • Infatuation, 2019

    The Best Pizza In Seattle

    Infatuation, 2019

Windy City Pie

Pizza, $$, SeattlePizza, $$Seattle, Phinney Ridge
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.5
  • Eater, 2020

    Seattle's Essential Pizza Restaurants

    Eater, 2020
  • SeattleMet, 2019

    Seattle’s Best Pizza: From Thick Crust to Thin

    SeattleMet, 2019

Pizzeria Pulcinella

Pizza, $$, SeattlePizza, $$Seattle, Rainier Beach
Google: 4.7
Yelp: 4.5
  • Infatuation, 2019

    The Best Pizza In Seattle

    Infatuation, 2019
  • Eater, 2020

    Seattle's Essential Pizza Restaurants

    Eater, 2020

Ballard Pizza Company

Pizza, $$, SeattlePizza, $$Seattle, Ballard
Google: 4.3
Yelp: 4.0
  • Eater, 2020

    Seattle's Essential Pizza Restaurants

    Eater, 2020
  • The Stranger, 2018

    Pizza Pie Face Off: Searching for the Best Slice in Seattle

    The Stranger, 2018

Why these restaurants?

Figuring out the best restaurants can take a long time. We analyzed 10951 Mercer Island restaurants on Yelp and Google, 1095134 Mercer Island restaurant reviews, and 1286 lists and articles – looking closely at what The Stranger, Eater and Infatuation had to say – and applied our boam magic. Yes, we even looked at The Stranger - Pizza Pie Face Off: Searching for the Best Slice in Seattle, Eater - Seattle's Essential Pizza Restaurants and Infatuation - The Best Pizza In Seattle to pull this list together. Our engine uses real-time data to only show restaurants that are open and their updated available services, so you can actually enjoy the food we show. Restaurants can’t pay to show up on this list, so enjoy the best food with no agenda. These ten options are sure to delight.

Parking tips

Nobody likes to circle around the block looking for parking, especially if you’re hungry or in a rush. If you want to avoid the struggle, our partners at SpotHero help you reserve a parking spot digitally before you even leave for your destination.

Also popular here

Similar spots in nearby neighborhoods

Show more