boam

The 15 Best Italian Restaurants Near Bay Harbor Islands

Updated: May 2, 2022

Anything better than pasta doused in parmesan? No! That's why you should visit Bay Harbor Islands’s best Italian restaurants. Don’t waste time agonizing, we analyzed millions of reviews to bring you the best Italian options in Bay Harbor Islands. Pick one of these Bay Harbor Islands eateries and enjoy delectable tiramisu or sip on Italian Chianti - your choice!

Find the perfect Italian restaurant

Emilio's Trattoria

Italian, $$, Bay Harbor IslandsItalian, $$Bay Harbor Islands
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.5

If you travel further

Sapore Di Mare

Italian, $$$, MiamiItalian, $$$Miami, North-East Coconut Grove
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.5
  • Eater, 2021

    15 Great Spots in Miami for Italian Cuisine

    Eater, 2021
  • Vacation Idea, 2021

    21 Best Italian Restaurants in Miami, Florida

    Vacation Idea, 2021

Macchialina Taverna Rustica

Italian, $$$, Miami BeachItalian, $$$Miami Beach, Flamingo Lummus
Google: 4.4
Yelp: 4.0
  • Miami and Beaches, 2021

    Best Italian Restaurants in Greater Miami & Miami Beach

    Miami and Beaches, 2021
  • Eater, 2021

    15 Great Spots in Miami for Italian Cuisine

    Eater, 2021

NiDo Caffe

Italian, $$, MiamiItalian, $$Miami, Upper Eastside
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.5
  • Eater, 2021

    15 Great Spots in Miami for Italian Cuisine

    Eater, 2021
  • Vacation Idea, 2021

    21 Best Italian Restaurants in Miami, Florida

    Vacation Idea, 2021

CRUST

Italian, $$, MiamiItalian, $$Miami, Downtown
Google: 4.7
Yelp: 4.5
  • Three Best Rated

    3 Best Italian Restaurants in Miami, FL

    Three Best Rated
  • Vacation Idea, 2021

    21 Best Italian Restaurants in Miami, Florida

    Vacation Idea, 2021

Mister O1- South Beach

Pizza, $$, Miami BeachPizza, $$Miami Beach, City Center
Google: 4.8
Yelp: 4.5
  • Gayot: The Guide to the Good Life

    2021 Best Pizza Restaurants in Miami/South Florida Area

    Gayot: The Guide to the Good Life
  • Infatuation

    The 21 Best Pizza Places In Miami

    Infatuation

Vero

Italian, $$, MiamiItalian, $$Miami, Downtown
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 4.5
  • Vacation Idea, 2021

    21 Best Italian Restaurants in Miami, Florida

    Vacation Idea, 2021

Palat Miami

Italian, $$, MiamiItalian, $$Miami, Little Haiti
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 4.5
  • Eater, 2021

    15 Spots to Cure Cacio e Pepe Cravings in Miami

    Eater, 2021

Fratellino

Italian, $$, MiamiItalian, $$Miami
Google: 4.8
Yelp: 5.0
  • Eater, 2021

    15 Great Spots in Miami for Italian Cuisine

    Eater, 2021

Scarpetta

Italian, $$$, Miami BeachItalian, $$$Miami Beach, Oceanfront
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.0
  • USA Today

    Best Italian Restaurants in Miami

    USA Today
  • Vacation Idea, 2021

    21 Best Italian Restaurants in Miami, Florida

    Vacation Idea, 2021

La Leggenda Pizzeria

Pizza, $$, Miami BeachPizza, $$Miami Beach, Flamingo Lummus
Google: 4.7
Yelp: 4.5
  • Infatuation

    The 21 Best Pizza Places In Miami

    Infatuation
  • Infatuation

    Where To Eat Outside In South Beach

    Infatuation

'O Munaciello

Italian, $$, MiamiItalian, $$Miami, Upper Eastside
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 4.5
  • Infatuation

    The 21 Best Pizza Places In Miami

    Infatuation
  • Infatuation

    The Best Restaurants In MiMo

    Infatuation

Lucali

Pizza, $$, Miami BeachPizza, $$Miami Beach, Bayshore
Google: 4.4
Yelp: 4.0
  • CultureTrip, 2017

    Best Pizza Places In Miami, Florida

    CultureTrip, 2017
  • Gayot: The Guide to the Good Life

    2021 Best Pizza Restaurants in Miami/South Florida Area

    Gayot: The Guide to the Good Life

Caffe Abbracci

Italian, $$, MiamiItalian, $$Miami
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 4.0
  • USA Today

    Best Italian Restaurants in Miami

    USA Today
  • Eater, 2021

    15 Superb Coral Gables Restaurants

    Eater, 2021

Andiamo

Pizza, $$, MiamiPizza, $$Miami, Upper Eastside
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.0
  • Gayot: The Guide to the Good Life

    2021 Best Pizza Restaurants in Miami/South Florida Area

    Gayot: The Guide to the Good Life
  • Three Best Rated

    3 Best Pizza Places in Miami, FL

    Three Best Rated

How was this list created?

We know how time consuming it can be to find the best Italian restaurants in Bay Harbor Islands. These results are brought to you by boam, with insights from the Yelp and Google ratings for 16799 Bay Harbor Islands restaurants, 823905 reviews, and 790 top lists and articles from the likes of Eater and Infatuation. Yes, we even looked at Eater - 15 Superb Coral Gables Restaurants, Infatuation - The Best Restaurants In MiMo and Infatuation - Where To Eat Outside In South Beach to pull this list together. We automatically update restaurants’ availability and services, so you can find a great meal as the industry adapts to COVID-19. Our site gets no money for featuring restaurants in this list – everyone’s earned their place. These ten options are sure to delight.

Frequently asked questions

Emilio's Trattoria and Foozo Artisan Pizza - Bay harbor are the highest-rated Italian restaurants for a quick lunch in Bay Harbor Islands.

There are 2 Italian restaurants in Bay Harbor Islands.

Emilio's Trattoria is the highest-rated Italian restaurant for delivery in Bay Harbor Islands.

Emilio's Trattoria is the highest-rated Italian restaurant for a date night in Bay Harbor Islands.

Emilio's Trattoria is the highest-rated upscale Italian restaurant in Bay Harbor Islands.

Drink pairing tips

  • The perfect complement to rabbit with sausage


    When having rabbit with sausage, experts suggest you pair it with a glass of Cabernet Sauvignon, a popular red wine.

  • Pinot Grigio with your tagliatelle pasta

    A nice white wine that will bring the most out of the creamy flavors of your tagliatelle pasta would be Pinot Grigio.

Interesting facts

  • A day for pasta-lovers

    Have you ever really wanted to celebrate pasta? People in The United Statesdo, every October 17, and they call it National Pasta Day.

  • The most lavish lasagna

    If you have recently won the lottery, or you just happen to have $100 lying around, why not spend it on indulging in the world’s most glamorous, and most expensive, lasagna?

  • The ideal pairing

    Should you find yourself on the streets of Italy be sure to sample the local campari one of the country's most classic and popular drinks!

Parking tips

Getting a good parking spot in Bay Harbor Islands can be tough, and it’s worse if you’re hungry. To make the hunt for parking easier, we’ve partnered with a cutting-edge digital parking reservation system, Spothero, that enables you to book a spot in advance before you visit your chosen Italian spot.

Also popular here

Similar spots in other neighborhoods

Show more

Similar spots in other areas

Show more