The 8 Best Pizza Places Near Amherst

Updated: September 21, 2022

Do you prefer a tomato base or is pizza Bianca your jam? Either way, these are the top pizza joints in Amherst. We analyzed food blogs, restaurant rankings, and millions of reviews for the best parlors in Amherst. Spoil yourself with a slice of Neapolitan or California pizza from these places doing this Italian classic best.

Find the perfect Pizza spot

Ziggy's Carry Out Cafe

Pizza, AmherstPizzaAmherst
Google: 4.4
Yelp: 5.0

Jilliano's Pizzeria

Pizza, $$, AmherstPizza, $$Amherst
Google: 4.4
Yelp: 3.5

D'Tutanelli's Pizza

Pizza, $$, AmherstPizza, $$Amherst
Google: 4.2
Yelp: 3.5

If you travel further

Dodies Dockside

Italian, LorainItalianLorain
Google: 4.8
Yelp: 4.5

Chapman's Food Mart

Pizza, $, LorainPizza, $Lorain
Google: 4.2
Yelp: 4.5

Lenoci's Spaghetti House

Italian, $$, LorainItalian, $$Lorain
Google: 4.4
Yelp: 3.5

Sambino's Pizza

Pizza, $, ElyriaPizza, $Elyria
Google: 3.8
Yelp: 4.0

Selenti's Pizza

Pizza, $$, LorainPizza, $$Lorain
Google: 4.1
Yelp: 3.5

How was this list created?

Choosing the right spot for Pizza can be tough, especially if you’re exploring new restaurants. These results are brought to you by boam, with insights from the Yelp and Google ratings for 5547 Amherst restaurants, 823905 reviews, and 209 top lists and articles from the likes of . For example, we considered as we sourced this ultimate list. Every option we show has been verified as open and offering key services when we recommend it, thanks to our real-time updates. This content is not sponsored by any restaurant or party, the restaurants shown are the real deal. If your next meal is in any of these ten restaurants, the Pizza aficionado in you will rejoice.


Ziggy's Carry Out Cafe, Sal & Al's Diner, and Olde Town Pizza House have outdoor seating and pizza in Amherst.

Olde Town Pizza House, Marco's Pizza, and D'Tutanelli's Pizza are the highest-rated vegetarian pizza spots in Amherst.

Ziggy's Carry Out Cafe, Sal & Al's Diner, and Olde Town Pizza House are the highest-rated pizza spots for dinner in Amherst.

There are 6 pizza spots in Amherst.

Ziggy's Carry Out Cafe, Sal & Al's Diner, and Olde Town Pizza House are the highest-rated pizza spots to get a quick lunch in Amherst.

Drink pairing tips for Pizza

  • Pair Manhattan with cheese pizza

    Manhattan is bitter and sweet and this makes it a great drink to have alongside your pairing_Dish_name. The pairing_drink_ingredients in the drink play nicely with the pairing_Dish_flavour_profile flavours in the food.

  • The ultimate drink pairing for quattro formaggi

    Knowing what to pair with quattro formaggi can be tricky. It’s worth exploring some cold beverage, particularly a glass of soda. This, sweet, cold beverage balances the cheesy and salty quattro formaggi .

  • The perfect match for your cheese and bacon pizza

    Experts suggest pairing a cheese and bacon pizza with a glass of old fashioned, a popular cocktail.

Factoids about Pizza

  • A new pizza record

    Joey Chestnut broke the world record by eating the most pizza in one sitting. The new record - that has not been beaten since - is 40 1/2 slices.

  • A classic meal

    A trip to The United States is incomplete without having tried the local pepperoni pizza, a national classic!

  • National Pizza with Everything except anchovies day Day in The United States

    National Pizza with Everything except anchovies day Day - have you ever heard of it? Well you better be ready to enjoy it if you’re in The United States on November 12.

Parking tips

Parking can be tough around Amherst To make your life easier, we partnered with SpotHero, an innovative digital parking reservation service, so you can easily and effortlessly find parking near your selected Pizza spot.

Also popular in this area

Pizza in other neighborhoods

Show more

Similar spots in other areas

Show more