boam

The 15 Best American Restaurants Near Worthington

Updated: October 10, 2022

Looking for Worthington’s best buffalo wings or spiciest chili? These are the American spots doing it best. We analyzed millions of reviews from the top local sites to compile This list of top American restaurants. If glasses of bloody mary and plates of crawfish sound like a good time head to these fantastic options in Worthington.

Find the perfect American restaurant

Over the Counter

New American, $$, WorthingtonNew American, $$Worthington
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.5

The Whitney House

American, $$, WorthingtonAmerican, $$Worthington
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 4.0

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH

Pizza, $$, WorthingtonPizza, $$Worthington
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.0

Amano's Sports Bar

Pizza, $$, WorthingtonPizza, $$Worthington
Google: 4.4
Yelp: 3.5

The Blarney Stone Tavern

New American, $$, WorthingtonNew American, $$Worthington
Google: 4.2
Yelp: 3.5

If you travel further

Third and Hollywood

American, $$, ColumbusAmerican, $$Columbus, Tri-Village
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 4.5
  • Hoodline, 2019

    Indulge on New American fare at these top Columbus eateries

    Hoodline, 2019
  • Lyft

    Top 10 Most Visited American Restaurants in Columbus

    Lyft

Mitchell's Ocean Club

New American, $$$$, ColumbusNew American, $$$$Columbus, Easton
Google: 4.7
Yelp: 4.5
  • Hoodline, 2019

    Indulge on New American fare at these top Columbus eateries

    Hoodline, 2019
  • Hoodline, 2019

    Columbus' top 5 steakhouses, ranked

    Hoodline, 2019

Harvest Bar + Kitchen

Pizza, $$, ColumbusPizza, $$Columbus, Clintonville
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 4.5
  • Hoodline, 2019

    The 5 best traditional American spots in Columbus

    Hoodline, 2019
  • Hoodline, 2019

    Jonesing for burgers? Check out Columbus's top 5 spots

    Hoodline, 2019

Hot Chicken Takeover

American, $$, ColumbusAmerican, $$Columbus, Whetstone
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 4.5
  • Hoodline, 2019

    The 5 best traditional American spots in Columbus

    Hoodline, 2019
  • Hoodline, 2019

    Here are Columbus's top 5 soul food spots

    Hoodline, 2019

Kai's Crab Boil

New American, $$, ColumbusNew American, $$Columbus, Olentangy Commons
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.5
  • Hoodline, 2019

    The 4 best New American spots in Columbus

    Hoodline, 2019
  • Hoodline, 2019

    The 4 best Cajun/Creole spots in Columbus

    Hoodline, 2019

Northstar Café

American, $$, ColumbusAmerican, $$Columbus, Victorian Village
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.5
  • Hoodline, 2019

    The 5 best New American spots in Columbus

    Hoodline, 2019
  • Hoodline, 2019

    Your guide to the 4 top spots in Columbus' Victorian Village neighborhood

    Hoodline, 2019

Lindey's

American, $$$, ColumbusAmerican, $$$Columbus, German Village Commission
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 4.0
  • Hoodline, 2019

    Indulge on New American fare at these top Columbus eateries

    Hoodline, 2019
  • Lyft

    Top 10 Most Visited American Restaurants in Columbus

    Lyft

South Village Grille

American, $$, ColumbusAmerican, $$Columbus, Merion Village
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 4.5
  • Hoodline, 2019

    Your guide to the 5 top spots in Columbus' German Village neighborhood

    Hoodline, 2019

Service Bar

American, $$$, ColumbusAmerican, $$$Columbus, Weinland Park
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 4.5
  • Hoodline, 2019

    Indulge on New American fare at these top Columbus eateries

    Hoodline, 2019

Matt and Tony's Wood Fired Kitchen

American, $$, ColumbusAmerican, $$Columbus, Brewery District (including Whittier Peninsula)
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.5
  • Hoodline, 2019

    3 new American spots in Columbus

    Hoodline, 2019

How does it work?

Finding the right American restaurant for you shouldn’t be so hard. We looked at Yelp and Google’s ratings for 5530 spots across Worthington, analyzed 823905 restaurant reviews, and sifted through 161 lists and articles from the likes of Hoodline – applying our boam magic to sift through results. We cross-referenced with top lists, like Hoodline - Your guide to the 5 top spots in Columbus' German Village neighborhood, Hoodline - Your guide to the 4 top spots in Columbus' Victorian Village neighborhood and Hoodline - Columbus' top 5 steakhouses, ranked. If it’s on the list, we’ve checked and verified that the restaurant is still open and will showcase any updated hours and services you need to be aware of. Restaurants can’t pay to show up on this list, so enjoy the best food with no agenda. Don’t sleep on the restaurants in this list.

Also popular in this area

Similar restaurants in nearby neighborhoods

Show more

Similar spots in other areas

Show more