boam

The 15 Best American Restaurants Near Pickerington

Updated: July 27, 2022

Looking for the best American restaurants in Pickerington? These are our top choices for gumbo and fried chicken. We analyzed millions of reviews from the top local sites to compile This list of top American restaurants. If glasses of bloody mary and plates of crawfish sound like a good time head to these fantastic options in Pickerington.

Find the perfect American restaurant

Hangry City Grille and Spirits

American, $, PickeringtonAmerican, $Pickerington
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.5

Jay's Crab Boil & Oyster Bar

American, $$, PickeringtonAmerican, $$Pickerington
Google: 4.4
Yelp: 3.5

MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub

American, $$, PickeringtonAmerican, $$Pickerington
Google: 4.2
Yelp: 3.0

If you travel further

Fillin’ Station

American, $, CarrollAmerican, $Carroll
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 5.0

Flavor 91 Bistro

American, $$, WhitehallAmerican, $$Whitehall
Google: 4.6
Yelp: 4.5

Shade On the Canal

American, $$, Canal WinchesterAmerican, $$Canal Winchester
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 4.0

Silohs

American, $, Canal WinchesterAmerican, $Canal Winchester
Google: 4.3
Yelp: 4.0

Flanagan's Pub

American, $, BlacklickAmerican, $Blacklick
Google: 4.2
Yelp: 4.0

The Hansom Hog

American, $$, GroveportAmerican, $$Groveport
Google: 4.5
Yelp: 3.5

Harvest Moon Craft Kitchen

American, $$, Canal WinchesterAmerican, $$Canal Winchester
Google: 4.4
Yelp: 3.5

The Ugly Mug Bar & Grill

American, $, Canal WinchesterAmerican, $Canal Winchester
Google: 4.4
Yelp: 3.5

Ziggy's

American, $, PataskalaAmerican, $Pataskala
Google: 4.4
Yelp: 3.5

Nico's Cajun Island

Creole, $$, ReynoldsburgCreole, $$Reynoldsburg
Google: 4.2
Yelp: 3.5

MCL Restaurant & Bakery

American, $$, WhitehallAmerican, $$Whitehall
Google: 4.3
Yelp: 3.0

The Barn On York

American, $, PataskalaAmerican, $Pataskala
Google: 4.3
Yelp: 3.0

How did we curate this list?

Finding the best American restaurant for you shouldn’t feel like a second job. We used our boam magic powers to analyze 823905 local restaurant reviews, Google and Yelp ratings for 5530 restaurants, and 161 lists and articles from top sources like . Yes, we even looked at to pull this list together. If it’s on the list, we’ve checked and verified that the restaurant is still open and will showcase any updated hours and services you need to be aware of. Our site gets no payment from the restaurants we show, so you can trust what you see. Don’t sleep on the restaurants in this list.

Questions & answers

Hangry City Grille and Spirits, A & J Wingburger, and Jay's Crab Boil & Oyster Bar are some of the highest-rated late-night American spots in Pickerington.

There are 14 American restaurants in Pickerington.

A & J Wingburger, LongHorn Steakhouse, and Scramblers are vegetarian-friendly American restaurants in Pickerington.

Hangry City Grille and Spirits, A & J Wingburger, and Jay's Crab Boil & Oyster Bar are the highest-rated American restaurants that are good for groups in Pickerington.

The highest-rated American restaurants for delivery in Pickerington are Hangry City Grille and Spirits, Jay's Crab Boil & Oyster Bar, and Scramblers.

Drink pairing tips

  • A great drink pairing for grilled burger

    Knowing what to pair with grilled burger can be tricky. It’s worth exploring some cocktail, particularly a glass of Margarita. This, sweet, cocktail balances the spicy and salty grilled burger.

  • Pair Vieux Carre with heavy meat dish

    When considering how to best enjoy your heavy meat dish, we would highlight how well a glass of Vieux Carre complements the dish as it cuts through the heaviness of the dish.


  • Take beef burger to the next level

    When having beef burger, experts suggest you pair it with a glass of Cabernet Sauvignon, a popular red wine.

Interesting facts

  • Celebrating American

    Pittsburgh, The United States is the proud home of the annual Picklesburgh Festival, held every July to celebrate everything that is good about American.


  • The priciest dish

    The mac and cheese which costs $200, can be ordered at the Barton G.

  • The go-to pairing

    If you’re gonna be eating hot dog, then we’d advise washing it down with a nice lemonade.

Parking tips

Parking can be tough around Pickerington To make the hunt for parking easier, we’ve partnered with a cutting-edge digital parking reservation system, Spothero, that enables you to book a spot in advance before you visit your chosen American spot.

Popular choices in this area

Similar restaurants in other areas

Show more

Similar spots in other areas

Show more